Sunday, 20 November 2016

Arbitrary vs. Necessary

Essentially, Hewitt describes arbitrary items, in a very natural way, as anything that doesn't follow from an earlier idea.  Here are some examples of arbitrary pieces of knowledge: names, real-life measures, definitions and first axioms, notations, etc.  Some of these may, in fact, follow from earlier rules, but many won't.  In any case, many of these "follow" from a previous arbitrary rule, so there's still no way to intuit them without knowing about the earlier case.  (For example: the measure of the English unit of weight, "stone".  There's a reason for it to be what it generally is, but no one would be able to just figure it out.)

Necessary things are those which follow from known ideas, even if those known ideas are arbitrary.  Basically, these are cases where if you know the basis, or can determine the basis, then you can determine the result.  Of course, it may be really hard to determine the result, but the point it that it's possible.

Regarding teaching, it's critical that teachers cover any required arbitrary knowledge.  The trick will be to make it memorable, since it generally and inherently isn't.  Conversely, wherever possible, students should be encouraged to work out necessary knowledge for themselves.  Although these items of knowledge can be deduced, they may still be quite difficult, though, so varying levels of scaffolding will likely be needed in order to help the students find their way.

Tuesday, 15 November 2016

Practicum Surprises

1.  I know a couple of the other teachers at the school, since my kids have played sports with their kids.  (I know this probably isn't the type of thing you meant, but still: I was surprised.)

2. My school doesn't have a very good scholastic reputation.  However, the kids showed a lot of spirit and engagement, in general.  I was very impressed with them.  (This just goes to show how little faith one should put in those types of things.)  That said, one administrator did acknowledge that the school did not have a particularly high academic standing, but also went on to tout other virtues, that were completely valid.

3. My teachers employ flipped classrooms.  One teacher began last year, and the other began this year.  My first reaction was terror, simply because I wasn't prepared for that eventuality at all.  However, the method is much more aligned with how I'd like to teach, so this is a great opportunityfor me.  (Note: Their grade 8 classes are taught more traditionally, as it's worried that the jump from elementary school is already a big change, and this might be too much for some to handle.  They are considering phasing it in a little over hte course of the year.)

4. Although I know it is important, observing classes makes me want to die.  Participating in classes is very fun, though.

5. My FA has very strong ideas about teaching, and teaching math especially, and I think they may not align with my ideas very well.  I'm worried.

Tuesday, 25 October 2016

Lesson Plan Feedbck

Here's a summary of the feedback for our Grade 8 lesson on ratios:
Feedback Summary Ali Rashi Inso Jon Nadi Litty Jason Hee jin John
Preparation of topic, lesson 3 3 3 3 2 2 3 3 3
Confidence, voice and presence in the role of teacher 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 3 3
Organisation and time management 1 2 2 1 2 1 1 2 1
Clarity of teaching 2 2 3 2 2 1 2 3 1
Classroom management/orchestrating the group 2 3 2 2 2 3 2 2 1
Collaboration amongst the co-teaching partners 3 3 3 1 3 3 2 2 1
Level of focus/engagement of learners 3 3 3 2 2 2 3 2 2

And here's a link to the original scanned pages.

Reflection

Our lesson did not follow the scipt we'd prepared.  However, rather than interrupt another teacher in front of the class, which would have been disrespectful and undermined the teacher's authority, we chose to be flexible and do our best to accomplish the goals of the lesson in a new way.  It was not easy, and it was certainly stressful, but the result was acceptable.  Although the students certainly suspected that something was not quite right, they still generally liked the lesson.  (The scores on the feedback attest to this.)  More importantly, they stayed engaged, and learned something.

Overall, this was a good reminder for us: things aren't always going to go to plan.  In fact, things probably won't go exactly to plan most of the time, so flexibility is absolutely required.  That said, hopefully, the lesson's won't often go as far off track as this one did.

Saturday, 22 October 2016

Tomato Soup Can

I'll make some guesses based simply on my viewing of the image:
- bike length is ~1.6m
- can radius is ~1.6m (or, one bike)
- can height is ~4.5m (or, a little less than 3 bikes)

This leads to a volume of approximately: (3.14)(1.6m)(1.6m)(4.5m).  Roughly, this gives 36 cubic metres, or about 9600 gallons.  According to one firefighting site, a typical small house fire will require 400 gallons per minute to fight, so as long as you can get the fire out in 24 minutes or less, then you should be ok. This seems risky to me.  ;)

Reflection

Estimation is difficult, especially when you are dealing with incomplete information.  In this case, as examples, it's not clear the tank is circular, really has the same ratio of dimensions to a soup can, and appears deformed.  However, the important thing is to justify the numbers chosen.

Tuesday, 18 October 2016

Team Microteaching Files

Here are links to the files needed for our grade 8 math lesson:
- lesson plan
- ratio presentation
- ratio handout

BCAMT Plan

BCAMT Schedule
 
10:00 Puzzles and Games: Is this Really Math? (E007)
11:00 A Pre-Calculus 12 Resource (B207)
12:30 Social Justice and mathematics (B204)

Saturday, 8 October 2016

Puzzle Solutions

Jason's Puzzle

Jason's puzzle really bothers me.  I got a solution, but my method was inelegant, ugly, and thus, fairly unsatisfying.  I pulled the following equations from the problem:
  50x + 20y + z = 1200
  x + y + z = 120

Next, I notice that z needs to be a multiple of 10, in order to have any chance at an answer.  It also must be between 0 and 120, and somewhere closer to the 120 end in order to balance with the other two factors.  I try 70 and 80, and they fail.  I try 90, and it gives me the following equations to solve:
  5x + 2y = 111
  x + y = 30

This gives x=17 and y=13, which works.  So, the answer is 17 men, 13 women, and 90 children went to the circus.  I bet there's a nicer way to think of this problem, though.


Hee jin's Puzzle

At first, I wondered if the father was trying to teach his children to share or cooperate or something.  I wondered whether they were supposed to try to reach Mecca at the same time, or make some kind of agreement to share the estate upon arrival.  But, this felt somehow unsatisfying.

So, I pondered it for awhile longer, and another option occurred to me.  This solution felt a lot more satisfying from a puzzle perspective, even though I was fundamentally disappointed in the greedy, unsharing nature of it.  But, upon a closer look, I could see a part of the text which confirmed my thinking.  Near the end, the two brothers don't jump on "their camels", which you'd expect; instead, they jump on "the camels."  The wise man suggested they trade camels, because then the first one to Mecca wins.

Wednesday, 5 October 2016

Math Puzzle

Here is a link to a scan of the puzzle I've selected.  My reasons for this selection?  First, it's a classic, and second, I really liked this particular presentation.

Tuesday, 4 October 2016

Letters from the Future

Dear Mr. Hawthorne,

I just wanted to let you know that I am doing well.  I finished a degree in Sociology recently, and I hope to find work in a high school.

I really appreciated participating in your math class in grade 8.  I finished elementary school with no interest in math, and a firm belief that I couldn't do it so there was no point trying.  I'm so glad that you showed me otherwise.  I started to do a lot better in math (and hate it less), and carried through to complete pre-calc 12, and that helped me gain entrance to the university program I wanted.  So, again, I just wanted to say thanks.

Regards,
 Sarah Beauregard

------------------

Mr. Hawthorne,

I wish that things had worked out differently in math class.  I didn't like the way you handled the class; it always seemed to include some falseness, even arrogance, and that turned me off.  It all came to a head that one time when you told me you thought I had more mathematical ability than I'd shown in class so far.  That was an attack that I just couldn't accept.  Anyway, it's too late now, but I still wanted you to know how I felt, so that you could consider changing your ways for future students.

Jeff Chaucer

-----------------

Reflection

I strive to present a genuine and natural enthusiasm for the subject, and to instill and build confidence in my students.  To potentially mis-speak or cause damage via some other action or inaction and fail in this endeavour causes me great worry.

Monday, 3 October 2016

My Past Teachers

Mr. Smith loved mathematics and teaching mathematics.  It was absolutely clear in every class of his I attended.  Although the classroom was set up in a traditional style, and the lecture delivery was very traditional, the class did not feel like every other class.  His warmth and genuine enthusiasm impacted all aspects of the class and I was always engaged.  He obviously wanted to share math with me, and I responded accordingly.

Mr. Jones seemed to really like mathematics, too.  However, his delivery was rigid and dry.  There was always a distance between the class and him.  To us students, it always seemed like he felt some small amount of disdain for us.  We were kept at a distance, and there was little (if any) enthusiasm or warmth on display.

Ultimately, these two cases reflect much of how I reacted to all of my teachers, and they impact the kind of presence I want within a classroom.  I want to project warmth, enthusiasm, and sincerity.  I want to welcome everyone to learn math with me.  It is my sincere desire to help others come to love math like I do, and have good experiences learning about it.

Saturday, 1 October 2016

"Wordy" Puzzles

Puzzle #1

I think the main question is: What is the relationship between the fiddler, piper, wife, and mother?

I first note that the group ate 3 full cakes, 3 half-cakes, and 3 quarter-cakes.  (I get momentarily distracted by the fact that the males are both musicians and the cake descriptions remind me of notes: full notes, half-notes, and quarter-notes.  But, I don't see a way forward in this direction so I move on.)  Regarding the cakes, the repetition of the "3" makes me wonder if the four people listed are actually just three people, but with one person described in two ways.  I also note that the cakes don't divide nicely into four portions, which I consider to be additional evidence for my suspicion.

About the people, it is certainly possible for one male to play both a fiddle and a pipe.  But, the way the two are so closely associated with a particular instrument makes me think it likely they are two separate people, each with his own specialty.  On the other hand, it is common for a female person to be both a wife and a mother at the same time.  Those labels are associated with the familial relationship which will differ depending on the person on the other end of the relationship.  So, I think the wife and mother are the same person.  As such, this makes the piper the son of the fiddler.

And to clean things up: if shared evenly, each person will have had one each of the full, half-, and quarter-cakes.


Puzzle #2

Since this puzzle is told in the first person, I think the question might be: Who am I?  Or, alternately: Who is "that man?"

I do a lot of work with my own family tree, so I imagine this simlarly, taking on the role of the writer.  As such, "I" appear to have no siblings.  I will, of course, still have a mother and father.  If that other man is also a son of my father, how can it be that we both have the same father, but are not brothers?  One way is that we could have different mothers, and are only half-brothers, as a result.  I think this satisfies the rule of the riddle, but it's not satisfying: I'd still consider "that man" to be a brother, at least in a sense.

I consider other possibilities.  The first that occurs to me is: what if "that man" and "I" are the same person?  Is there a way for that to be true?  So, I wonder if I'm looking at myself in a mirror, or perhaps at myself in a picture.  This satisfies the riddle, I think, and it's more satisfying to me.  I note that when I look in the mirror now, I see a man that is, in a sense, not me.  I associate my inner view of myself  as much younger than I appear in the mirror, for example.  In a way, my reflection in a mirror is much different than I expect, and thus appears a bit of a stranger.  In any case, I'm not sure this is the actual answer sought by the riddle, but I am happy with it.


Reflection

Generally, I examined these puzzles in a similar fashion.  I looked for patterns and relationships.  These riddles happened to involve actual familial relationships, but that needn't be the case.  I'd approach most puzzles similarly, even if they weren't about people.

Tuesday, 27 September 2016

Kadinsky Math/Art Reflection

First, here are links to the Base 6 items I worked on: Blank, Rainbow, and Shaded.

This exercise was a good reminder for me, both pedagogically and personally.  I had long buried the artistic side of my mathematical learning experience.  But, I had a lot of fun doing this art project, and part of that enjoyment surrounded my memories of elementary school.  In my middle elementary grades, I would often spend much of the math portion of the class using my ruler and pencil to make designs on blank paper.  These varied in form, but often involved measuring, and connecting points to see what patterns developed.  They weren't especially advanced or anything, but I had fun doing them (instead of paying attention to the actual math lesson).  My teachers were quite supportive, actually, and would often make photocopies of my results, which we'd colour in the art portion of class.

At the time, of course, I didn't really think of these pursuits as either art or math.  They were just something I felt drawn to do and had fun doing.  I have always loved to search out patterns.  In hindsight, thought, I can see more clearly that they were a method by which I explored both subjects.

So, as I said, this was a good reminder for me.  I look forward to being able to bring this into my own class some day.  And, similarly, as I like gardening and nature, I look forward to future explorations in the garden, where I can look for more patterns, and consider ways to bring that into the math classroom, as well.

Wednesday, 21 September 2016

TPI


The TPI results generally supported what I already knew.  First, my focus is almost completely divorced from societal factors.  It's clear this is an area that I will need to think more about, given our continually-diversifying society.

Second, my focus is clearly nurture.  I worry most about the kids who have a less easy time with Maths and with school in general.  I want to help build them up; increase their confidence and hopefully, their sense of self-worth.  I want to do this via engaging them in the discovery of mathematics, and by helping them encounter increasing success along the way.  If, along the way, I can build in them some critical thinking skills, investigation skills, perseverance and resilience, then I'll be a happy teacher.  :)

Tuesday, 20 September 2016

How Many Squares in a Chessboard?

At first, I considered just counting cases of squares in the chessboard.  For example, counting all the 1x1 squares, then the 2x2 squares, and so on up to the 8x8 squares.  Then, I could simply add them up. 

But, I didn't really like this idea.  I was more curious to see if there might be a pattern.  So, I started with a 1x1 chessboard, and counted the squares.  (Pretty easy, eh? There's just the one square.)  But I then considered a 2x2 board, and a then a 3x3 board, and so on. The results look like the following:


Size List of Squares Total
1x1 1 (1x1) 1
2x2 1 (2x2), 4 (1x1) 5
3x3 1 (3x3), 4 (2x2), 9 (1x1) 14
4x4 1 (4x4), 4 (3x3), 9 (2x2), 16 (1x1) 30
5x5 1 (5x5), 4 (4x4), 9 (3x3), 16 (2x2), 25 (1x1) 55

And so on...  The pattern is pretty easy to recognise and generalise: A chessboard of size NxN will have the number of squares equal to 12 + 22 + 32 + … + N2.  When the pattern emerged, I freely confess I felt some joy to see it.

So, for an 8x8 chessboard,there will be 1+4+9+16+25+36+49+64 = 204 squares.

In class, if no one had looked at the basic pattern, I 'd ask them to try to come up with one for a generic NxN chessboard.  If someone had, I'd ask them to show it on the white board.  I might consider other alterations, such as asking for the number of squares where the length was even, or area was even?  Or, I might ask how many cubes in an 8x8x8 cube.

Saturday, 17 September 2016

Magic Square Puzzles

Please see the main blog for the rules associated with the following two puzzles:

So, how shall we start the first puzzle?  We have products, so we'll be looking at the factors that make up those products.  A good place to start is by considering the largest, smallest, or most "unusual" product.  This can help us find unambiguous options.  Let's look at the smallest, and only odd, product: 21.  The prime factors are 3x7.  We can also use 1 to give us three  factors.  We now know that this column consists of 1,3, and 7, but we must figure out where each digit goes.  Looking at the products for the rows, 7 is not a factor of 24 or 40, but is a factor of 378, so now we know the 7 goes in the bottom row of the middle column.  Similarly, 3 is not a factor of 40, but is a factor of 24, so it goes in the top row.  That leaves the middle row for the 1. 

Next, let's consider the biggest product: 378.  We have already determined that 7 is one of the factors, but what are the others?  Since 378/7 = 54, we know we need two single digit numbers that have a product of 54.  The only option is 6x9.  We can also note that 6 and 9 have not yet been used in the puzzle.  (This is a good test to help detect errors and contradictions.  Also, if there had been another possible pair, it might have been eliminated by looking at the digits that we'd already determined.  Or, it might have led to another case to consider.  Try to find unique cases first whenever possible.)  Since 9 is not a factor of 60, and 6 is, we know the 6 must go in the left column, leaving the right column for the 9.  (Always look for ways to check: 9 is indeed a factor of 288 which suggests we've made no mistakes so far.)

Proceeding in a similar fashion, we arrive at a solution. Along the way, we didn't encounter any ambiguous cases, so this is the only solution.





The second puzzle introduces the wrinkle that one of the products is not known.  We can start similarly, and note that the product 28 can only be achieved via the digits 1, 4, and 7.  Since 7 is not a factor of 40 or 48, it must go in the right column.  However, 1 and 4 are valid factors for both 40 and 48, so we can't immediately place them.  We can proceed by considering two cases, one where they appear in the order 1 then 4, and the other 4 then 1. The two cases would look like the following:
  

After this, we can proceed normally, looking at each case separately.  Along the way, we may encounter additional ambiguous cases that further split the investigation.  We may also find that some cases lead to eventual contradictions and are dead ends.

Eventually, though, we'll arrive at a solution.


Reflection

Puzzles can always be a fun way to look at math.  They need to be tailored to the class level, though, so that most students will be able to derive some satisfaction from them.  These, in particular, will be very useful for review of factoring, including prime factorisation.  Learning to factor typically involves a lot of rote practicing, so breaking it up with something more fun could make it more enjoyable and more memorable.  I suspect the difficulty could be tailored (by using more unique combinations, or by reducing the size, etc.) so that they could be employed in many different classes, including elementary.

Tuesday, 13 September 2016

Richard Skemp: Relational vs. Instrumental Understanding

At one point, the article notes, without offering any statistical evidence, that something learned relationally will be more lasting than something learned instrumentally.  I think this is the intutive position of many mathematicians (i.e. people who are good at mathematics), and I've always held it myself.  It occurs to me, though, that this may be oversimplifiying the situation, and maybe to the detriment of students.

To be fair, I suspect studies have been performed to determine this is so, but I wonder whether their "statistically significant" results go much into the length and strength of the difference, and how it might change for children of different abilities or at different levels of mathematical maturity.  If it's only minutes, hours, or even days, I'd like to know.

Like everyone, I've experienced instances where something I've learned (or something I've just experienced in my life) has stayed with me much longer than would typically be expected.  In all these cases, the event or experience struck me powerfully in some way.  It's clear a connection in the brain has been created that isn't typical; it's stronger.  Emotionally, it seems to me that these almost always involve an amazing sense of wonder.

So, I now wonder whether some of those kids who really struggle with Maths may be apt to have this amazing experience through cases of instrumental learning as often, or even more often, than through cases of relational learning.  Can they not have powerful "Eureka" moments, too, but just from different experiences?  I suspect it entirely depends on the situation for the child, and isn't as straight-forward as the article suggests.

Monday, 12 September 2016

Hello, World!

This is the blog of John Hawthorne, a student in EDCP342A in 2016.