At one point, the article notes, without offering any statistical evidence, that something learned relationally will be more lasting than something learned instrumentally. I think this is the intutive position of many mathematicians (i.e. people who are good at mathematics), and I've always held it myself. It occurs to me, though, that this may be oversimplifiying the situation, and maybe to the detriment of students.
To be fair, I suspect studies have been performed to determine this is so, but I wonder whether their "statistically significant" results go much into the length and strength of the difference, and how it might change for children of different abilities or at different levels of mathematical maturity. If it's only minutes, hours, or even days, I'd like to know.
Like everyone, I've experienced instances where something I've learned (or something I've just experienced in my life) has stayed with me much longer than would typically be expected. In all these cases, the event or experience struck me powerfully in some way. It's clear a connection in the brain has been created that isn't typical; it's stronger. Emotionally, it seems to me that these almost always involve an amazing sense of wonder.
So, I now wonder whether some of those kids who really struggle with Maths may be apt to have this amazing experience through cases of instrumental learning as often, or even more often, than through cases of relational learning. Can they not have powerful "Eureka" moments, too, but just from different experiences? I suspect it entirely depends on the situation for the child, and isn't as straight-forward as the article suggests.
What a lovely idea about the sense of wonder connected with more intense and enduring learning. You might be interested in reading some of Nathalie Sinclair and Peter Liljedahl's work on wonder and 'aha moments' in mathematics learning. I think both are published in a journal called For the Learning of Mathematics -- I can help you find these if you'd like to follow up!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the information. I am definitely interested in learning more in this area, but the question is: when? Maybe Christmas, I suppose, as right now I am still too overwhelmed with these classes.
DeleteChristmas might be a good time for a little recreational math ed reading -- after that big dinner, I like to settle down with some family puzzle solving and a few juicy articles! I will email a few articles to you. PS: In case the idea of 'lesson starters' doesn't yield many articles for your Inquiry project (for the EDUC 450 class), here's another potential topic idea.
Delete