Jason's Puzzle
Jason's puzzle really bothers me. I got a solution, but my method was inelegant, ugly, and thus, fairly unsatisfying. I pulled the following equations from the problem:
50x + 20y + z = 1200
x + y + z = 120
Next, I notice that z needs to be a multiple of 10, in order to have any chance at an answer. It also must be between 0 and 120, and somewhere closer to the 120 end in order to balance with the other two factors. I try 70 and 80, and they fail. I try 90, and it gives me the following equations to solve:
5x + 2y = 111
x + y = 30
This gives x=17 and y=13, which works. So, the answer is 17 men, 13 women, and 90 children went to the circus. I bet there's a nicer way to think of this problem, though.
Hee jin's Puzzle
At first, I wondered if the father was trying to teach his children to share or cooperate or something. I wondered whether they were supposed to try to reach Mecca at the same time, or make some kind of agreement to share the estate upon arrival. But, this felt somehow unsatisfying.
So, I pondered it for awhile longer, and another option occurred to me. This solution felt a lot more satisfying from a puzzle perspective, even though I was fundamentally disappointed in the greedy, unsharing nature of it. But, upon a closer look, I could see a part of the text which confirmed my thinking. Near the end, the two brothers don't jump on "their camels", which you'd expect; instead, they jump on "the camels." The wise man suggested they trade camels, because then the first one to Mecca wins.
Aha! Interesting solution to Heejin's puzzle! I find this more satisfying (from a puzzle point of view) than the (more brotherly-love) idea that they arrived at the same moment and shared the inheritance.
ReplyDeleteGood solution to Jason's puzzle, though I agree that it would be nice to have a more elegant approach available. However, since it's a problem in three variables with only two equations, some guess-and-check may be necessary, and the restriction on the z (that it has to be a multiple of 10) helps with that process.
ReplyDelete